NEW JERSEY DIVORCE & FAMILY LAW

Divorce Mediation in New Jersey: Why You Still Need a Lawyer

By Steven J. Kaplan, Esq. May 27, 2020 3 min read

Mediation can be one of the most effective ways to resolve a New Jersey divorce.

Instead of asking a judge to decide every disagreement, you and your spouse work with a neutral mediator to try to reach an agreement.

Mediation may reduce conflict, provide more control over the outcome, and help avoid the time and expense of a divorce trial.

But mediation does not mean you should go through your divorce without someone protecting your interests.

How Does Divorce Mediation Work in New Jersey?

During mediation, a neutral mediator helps you and your spouse discuss and potentially resolve issues such as:

  • Division of property and debts
  • Alimony
  • Child custody
  • Parenting time
  • Child support
  • College expenses
  • Insurance and other financial matters

The mediator does not represent either spouse and should not take sides.

Some spouses attend mediation with their attorneys. Others meet with the mediator directly and consult their individual attorneys before accepting an agreement.

Either way, you should understand that the mediator is not your lawyer.

Why You Still Need Your Own Divorce Attorney

A mediator’s job is to help both spouses reach an agreement. The mediator’s job is not to determine whether the agreement is the best possible result for you.

Your own divorce attorney can:

  • Explain your rights under New Jersey law
  • Identify assets, income, or risks that may have been overlooked
  • Evaluate proposed custody and support arrangements
  • Prepare you for mediation
  • Negotiate on your behalf
  • Review the final agreement before you sign it

A mediated agreement can affect your finances, children, and future for many years.

You should not agree to its terms until you understand exactly what they mean.

Mediation Does Not Mean Giving In

Some people assume that choosing mediation means they must be passive or agree to whatever their spouse proposes.

That is not true.

You can work toward a respectful settlement while still protecting yourself.

My role when representing a client in mediation is to help that client pursue a fair agreement, recognize unreasonable proposals, and avoid decisions that may create serious problems later.

You can be cooperative without being unprotected.

You can seek compromise without surrendering your rights.

The Potential Benefits of Divorce Mediation

Mediation may offer several advantages over prolonged divorce litigation:

  • You and your spouse retain more control over the outcome.
  • Discussions can occur in a more private setting.
  • Scheduling may be more flexible.
  • Legal expenses may be lower.
  • The process may involve less conflict.
  • Parents may be better positioned to communicate after the divorce.

This can be especially valuable when parents will need to continue making decisions together for their children.

Even after a divorce is completed, former spouses may return to mediation if a new disagreement develops. Resolving the issue through mediation may help them avoid another contested court proceeding.

Is Mediation Right for Every Divorce?

No.

Mediation works best when both spouses are willing to provide honest financial information, negotiate in good faith, and consider reasonable solutions.

It may be more difficult when a case involves:

  • Domestic violence or intimidation
  • A severe imbalance of power
  • Hidden income or assets
  • Substance abuse
  • Serious mental health concerns
  • A spouse who refuses to compromise
  • A spouse determined to delay or manipulate the process

That does not automatically make mediation impossible. It means the process may require additional safeguards, careful preparation, and strong legal representation.

Sometimes litigation is necessary.

The right approach depends on the people involved and the particular facts of the case.

My Experience With Divorce Mediation

My mediation experience began while I was attending law school. In 1982, I completed general mediation training through the Metropolitan Assistance Corporation, Victim Services Agency/Travelers’ Aid Services in Brooklyn and received a Mediator’s Certification Award.

I no longer serve as the neutral mediator.

Instead, I represent individual clients in mediation and, when necessary, in divorce litigation.

That background allows me to understand the process from both perspectives. I know how mediators approach settlement discussions, but my responsibility is always to protect the client I represent.

The Bottom Line

Divorce mediation in New Jersey can help you and your spouse reach a fair agreement without turning every issue into a courtroom battle.

But the mediator is neutral.

Your attorney is the person whose job is to protect you.

If you are considering mediation, speak with an experienced New Jersey divorce lawyer before accepting or signing any agreement. A seemingly minor provision can have significant consequences years later.

Learn Before You Make Your Next Move

I’ve specialized in New Jersey divorce law for 38 years and have been involved in more than 5,000 divorce cases.

I created my free DIVORCE SMARTER course to help people understand the New Jersey divorce process before making important decisions.

The course explains:

  • How divorce and mediation work
  • How to protect your children and assets
  • What makes a settlement fair
  • Which mistakes can weaken your position
  • How to prepare before negotiating with your spouse

The information is delivered in plain English, one short email at a time.

If you are considering divorce mediation, learn how the process works before agreeing to anything that may shape your future.

Steve

NEED LEGAL GUIDANCE?

Protect what matters. Plan what comes next.

Divorce can put everything you've worked hard to build at stake. Get experienced guidance and a clear strategy for moving forward.

SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION