Why The NJ Grounds For Divorce Don't Really Matter

racecar named "Ground for Divorce"

Since January 2007 NJ grounds for divorce have included  "irreconcilable differences.”

What are irreconcilable differences?

Pretty much anything.

What is interesting is that prior to the irreconcilable differences law, although there were quite a few different NJ grounds for divorce, most divorce lawyers, including me, filed most of our divorce complaints based upon "extreme cruelty.”

What exactly is extreme cruelty? Well… pretty much anything.

This led to some "creative" divorce complaints, like "...he intentionally spilled red wine on my white blouse during Christmas dinner of 2006, thereby intentionally embarrassing me in front of my whole family, including my Aunt Tillie" (dramatic embellishment added, just to make my point.)

Then what was the big deal about the introduction of the "irreconcilable differences" law thirteen years ago?

I mean, if pretty much anything constitutes irreconcilable differences, and if pretty much anything constituted extreme cruelty in the old days, what's the big deal?

The big deal is that since the passage of the irreconcilable differences statute 13 years ago, now that people can get divorced simply because they have differences that can't be reconciled, that's all they need to list in their divorce papers as their grounds for divorce.

In the old days, before the irreconcilable differences statute was passed here in New Jersey, someone seeking a divorce here had to make out a true case for divorce based upon one of the then stated grounds for divorce in NJ, which almost always turned out to be extreme cruelty.

In those days, most judges would accept anything that one person said about the other as meeting the requirements of "extreme cruelty."

But the law encouraged people to air all of their dirty laundry in the guise of pleading a cause of action for divorce based upon extreme cruelty, and when the receiving spouse read the allegations of"extreme cruelty" alleged against him or her, he or she would often get very upset.

The problem is that this unfortunate situation would often cause the divorce to start off on the wrong foot in many cases, leading to much unnecessary pain for parents and children, and perhaps huge legal fees because one party was hurt about what the other party said about them and thus "retaliated" with litigation tactics that often were unnecessary and counterproductive.

I advocated strongly for the passage of New Jersey's irreconcilable differences statute as an addition to the grounds for divorce in NJ prior to the passage of this law. As a New Jersey divorce lawyer for many years, I saw how much damage the prior laws had done.

We have been fortunate here in New Jersey for the past thirteen years that our legislature finally enacted an irreconcilable differences statute for those people who are seeking to divorce amicably. 



If you would like to receive cutting-edge NJ divorce information from me, delivered directly to your email once each day starting right now for the next month, then sign up for my Daily Dose of Divorce emails below.

We will not send you Spam but rather only helpful, insightful information about how to best solve important divorce-related topics in New Jersey.

Your first Daily Dose of Divorce email will arrive a few minutes after you sign up, and then once every 24 hours, for the next 31 days

You can unsubscribe at any time...but few people do.

Steven J. Kaplan, Esq.

Law Practice Specializing In
Divorce and Related Issues

5 Professional Circle
Colts Neck, NJ. 07722

(732) 845-9010

Topics: nj grounds for divorce